In a recent paper, scientists from the United States, Russia and India, have concluded that the Indus Valley Civilization was the result of a mixing of South Asians and Iranian peoples.
The study also concludes that the group previously known as “Aryan” were in fact pastoral communities from Central Asia which moved south from the steppe into the Indus Valley.
The study examined the DNA of 612 ancient individuals from across Central Asia, Iran and South Asia. This data was then compared with the DNA of 246 distinct groups in South Asia.
The study identified the Ancestral North Indian and the Ancestral South Indian as the result of the mixing and combination of three potential groups of peoples:
- The South Asian hunter-gatherers, the indigenous inhabitants of the subcontinent;
- The Iranian agriculturalists who migrated into the subcontinent, and;
- The Steppe pastoralists who were also migrants into the subcontinent.
The study provided the following outline based on this genetic data:
- The Indus Valley Civilization arises through the mixing of South Asians and Iranians;
- The “Aryan” civilization arises through the migration of Steppe pastoralists into the Indus Valley around the 2nd millennium BCE;
- Some of the Indus Valley moves further south where they mix with more South Asians, creating the Ancestral South Indian population;
- In the North, the Steppe pastoralists mix with the remaining Indus Valley population, creating the Ancestral North Indian population.
- Subsequent South Asians are a result of mixing between Ancestral North Indians and Ancestral South Indians.
The implication of this is that there was an “Aryan migration” into the subcontinent from the outside and not vice-versa. That suggestion will anger with the Hindu Rights with its inference that their ancestors and ancestral religion (including the Vedas) originated outside of the subcontinent.
This would undermines the Hindu Right’s claims that they are the original inhabitants of India vis-à-vis those following foreign religions. It also suggests that modern South Asians are a mix of what we previously called “Aryan” and “Dravidian,” with no such thing as a “pure race” or “nation” which is basic to Hindutva.
The Hindu Right is already rewriting history books in India. It is already censoring any views and ideas that would suggest India is the creation of anything but the primordial Hindu Nation. This paper will not affect the momentum of that project, but it does throw to the wind some of the theories on which Hindutva rests.
– Thanks to Satdeep, for inspiration across continents